Historical China is a cultural information website with Chinese history as the core, providing ancient Chinese history, economy and culture, Chinese medicine health care, painting and calligraphy, antique, religious philosophy, etc.

Several puzzling questions from the Qin Dynasty to the Han Dynasty

The 30 years since Qin Shihuang unified China to the founding of the Great Han in Liu Bang is arguably the most thrilling and bloody era in Chinese history:

The iron armor of the Great Qin swept the world like a sweep, the overlord Xiang Yu was unparalleled in history, the soldier Han Xin wielded his army freely, the civilian Liu Bangjun came to the world, the counselor Zhang Liang was at ease in the world, Xiao Shi ruled China... it was really a golden iron horse. Heroes are coming out in large numbers!

But when we are full of thoughts and feelings, we shouldn't have the eight major suspense left by the Qin Dynasty.

Where do the soldiers go?

Known as the first warrior of China, who broke the Qi State, and Guan Bai’s internal history led an army of 300,000 troops to attack the Xiongnu, regained Henan (now Hetao, South Ordos, Inner Mongolia), built the Great Wall of China and the Kyushu straight road, even though it was in AD In 210 BC, Hu Hai committed suicide after swallowing medicine after ascending the throne. But where has the army that has been in command of the nine counties for more than ten years gone?

After Qin Shihuang ruled the world, he retained two great Qin armies, one was Zhao Tuo's 500,000 army that attacked Lingnan, and the other was Meng Tian's 300,000 army that fought against the Huns. Although this army fought against the nomads is not much in history, it is conceivable from Li Mu's army that its combat strength is conceivable, and it is a direct line of the Daqin army. However, it was the Lishan Slave Army led by Zhang Han who fought against Xiang Yu. Since then, there has been no war. According to the Qin system, "the generals are in", but this army has disappeared without a trace.

Lishan Army is definitely not this soldier, because Lishan and the Great Wall are fellow practitioners. In view of the fact that from the end of the Qin war to the struggle for hegemony between the Chu and Han dynasties, none of the king's army and Han Xin's Northern Expedition were threatened by the Huns. Perhaps this horse is still guarding the Great Wall. But if this is the case, why didn't he participate in the counterinsurgency war? And there is no record of the establishment of Dahan?

Why didn't Zhao Tuo be North Aid?

As the commander-in-chief of the 500,000 army after Qin ruled the world, Zhao Tuo should be more trusted than Meng Tian. In the history of Qin, only Bai Qi and Wang Jian are comparable to the people who lead the army. From the perspective of Qin Shihuang’s employment, it is still There is really no wrong general's precedent.

Then, in the decades from the end of the Qin war to the beginning of the dynasty, why didn't Zhao Lun lead his army back to help?

Even if Zhao Tuo has the heart to support his soldiers and stand on his own, Xiang Yu Liu Bang is on the front line of Huanghuai and Zhao Tuo has hundreds of thousands of iron armors. It should be easy to level Wu and Chu in the south of the Yangtze River. What's more, its army went south, the Lingqu passed early, and the soldiers and horses fought back, which can be called a broad road.

What’s even stranger is that the 500,000 Qin army are all children of Guanzhong. How can they tolerate the death of soldiers in their native land and the death of their elders?

Lishan, what does it mean to be free from fire?

Qin tyranny, uprising soldiers. Xiang Jiajun and Qin Shihuang had the hatred of the family and the country, and Xiang Yu brought down the Zhanghan troops who built the Lishan Qin Mausoleum. Although they killed 200,000 Qin soldiers, the Mausoleum of the Shihuang Mausoleum had accumulated abundance and people’s grievances. Xiang Yu should Knowing well, and leaving Zhang Han to wait, he is also the natural guide to break the Qinling Mausoleum. Why did Xiang Yu sweep Xianyang and set it on fire, but did not care about the Mausoleum of Qin Shihuang in Lishan?

Xiang Yu had three generations of feuds with Qin Shihuang!

And since the Warring States period, digging and whip corpses has not been taboo-Xiang Yu also killed two hundred thousand Qin army and Xianyang massacre, and he would not be afraid of "extreme revenge for digging graves."

Who leveled the land of Shu Chu Wu?

Xiang Liang attacked in Huiji (now Suzhou), Chen Sheng attacked in Daze Township (now Suzhou), Liu Bang attacked in Pei County, centered on Pengcheng (now Xuzhou), Qin Chu fought decisively at Julu (now Xingtai), and Liu Bang marched from Nanyang. It just happens to be useless to the south of the Yangtze River.

Qin operated Shuzhong very early, and also pacified Chu State-mainly in Hubei, Hunan, Zhejiang and Jiangxi Fujian today. Why don't the places hear the sound of soldiers?

Liu Bang was sealed in Hanzhong and entered the Three Qin Dynasty with all his strength. Liu Bangshun Qinhuai headed east, Han Xin walked north to level Wei Zhao Yanqi, but did not look south, then when, who and how to settle the vast land of Chu, Wu and Yue?

Are the Hundred Scholars here today?

Seven heroes competed for hegemony, hundreds of families entered the Qin Dynasty, overwhelmingly overwhelmingly, and scholars overwhelmingly became one of the decisive factors in Qin's dominance. There are still three thousand guests under Lu Xiangmen. But only Xu Fuxing deceived the East into the sea, and Confucian scholars fell into the pit. Where did the rest of the sword-riding knights, learned men, geniuses, and thousands of guests belong?

Judging from the existing historical biography, Fan Zeng who helped Chu, Zhang Liang, Chen Ping and Han Xin who helped the Han Dynasty were not from the Qin region. When the rebels detained the pass, there was no outstanding person in the Qin area, and no high-level theory was passed down. At the beginning of the Han Dynasty, only Shangshan Sihao was named.

At the beginning of such a grand talent formation, no one can survive in troubled times, and one family can keep learning. It can be said?

Why doesn't Xiang Yu ask Yubi?

Li Si mentioned in the last "Book of Admonitions to the Guest": "The jade of your Majesty to Kunshan today is the treasure of easy and harmonious." "The treasure of easy and harmonious" refers to "the pearl of Suihou" and "the bi of the family". Two famous treasures at the time.

He Shi Bi is arguably the most famous treasure in the Warring States Period, and became a symbol of the emperor in the Qin Dynasty. Xiang Yu, who is aspiring to the king, and Fan Zeng of Yi and Kyushu, did not ask about it when Liu Bang offered a bi at the Hongmen Banquet. Isn’t it a big surprise?

Why did the Overlord forget Jiuding?

Since Yu cast Jiuding like Jiuzhou, Jiuding has become the symbol of the lord of the world. The king of Chu was defeated when he was defeated by different wills, and Qin defeated Zhou to take Jiuding in 256 years ago.

Liu Bang first entered the pass, and Ziying offered to surrender. Although the warehouse was closed and the troops were returned, Xiang Yu entered the pass without asking even the Jiuding, which is the most symbol of royal power. Isn’t it absurd?

If Xiang Yu killed Liu Bang with the "crime of losing the Dingbi", how could Liu Bang justify his claim? Why bother to make a banquet of the Hongmen?

Why is there no garrison on the plank road?

Li Bing governs Shu, the middle of Sichuan is prosperous, and the plank road has been transported for hundreds of years. There must be a soldier's store to transfer and protect it. Such a natural danger is really a trend of a man who is a man.

Even in the end of the Qin Dynasty, the two Sichuan provinces were confessed and confessed. Then Xiang Yu knew that there was Hanzhong, but Hanzhong had no ambitions? How did Xiang Yu know that Hanzhong was a bitter and poor place? How could Liu Bang bring "30,000 tired soldiers". Easy to enter Sichuan?

The Shuzhong county guard who was entrusted by Qin Shihuang was not as talented as Zhang Lu's generation? So Cao Cao didn't dare to raise his mind, why couldn't Liu Bang succeed?

Share: